Free download. Book file PDF easily for everyone and every device. You can download and read online Oxford Readings in Aristophanes (Oxford Readings in Classical Studies) file PDF Book only if you are registered here. And also you can download or read online all Book PDF file that related with Oxford Readings in Aristophanes (Oxford Readings in Classical Studies) book. Happy reading Oxford Readings in Aristophanes (Oxford Readings in Classical Studies) Bookeveryone. Download file Free Book PDF Oxford Readings in Aristophanes (Oxford Readings in Classical Studies) at Complete PDF Library. This Book have some digital formats such us :paperbook, ebook, kindle, epub, fb2 and another formats. Here is The CompletePDF Book Library. It's free to register here to get Book file PDF Oxford Readings in Aristophanes (Oxford Readings in Classical Studies) Pocket Guide.
Top Authors

Browse more videos

What readers of both sorts want and need above all else are thus short, highly readable articles that focus on individual plays i. The Oxford Readings in Aristophanes, on the other hand, average over twenty pages in length only one is under ten , and the majority are either quite technical e. Zimmermann's analysis of the development of the Aristophanic parabasis over time, or Gelzer's line-by-line study of how jokes are set up and dramatic tension maintained at the beginning of Birds or concerned with a whole series of plays rather than with one in particular.


  • Product description?
  • Account Options.
  • Greek Journeys | Hendrix College.

Indeed, the only plays to which complete individual essays are devoted in this collection are Acharnians, Clouds, Birds, and Ecclesiazusae, and Frogs in particular is almost entirely ignored. At the same time, although all Greek has been transliterated, much of it has not been translated, and the result is sentences like "The strange idea of the old men that someone who wants to stop their philodikia, which toin theoin psephismata guarantee The glossary on pp.

German, Italian, and even Latin also persist in both footnotes and text e.

Catullus (Oxford Readings in Classical Studies)

Professional but non-specialist readers will find the individual essays in this volume more accessible, and will also be inclined to welcome the Introduction, which attempts to offer a synoptic overview of recent scholarship on Aristophanes. There are also a number of specific omissions and errors that will reduce the value of this essay somewhat for the average non-specialist reader. In the discussion of bibliographies p.

Numerous typographical errors and the like are also to be found throughout this essay, 1 and it must be said in this context that the new Readings in Aristophanes as a whole is not quite up to Oxford's traditionally very high standards of editing and proofreading. Particularly unfortunate is the fact that footnotes have not been handled in a consistent fashion, but have instead been removed altogether from some essays probably appropriate for a volume of this sort , while being allowed to occupy up to half the page in others e.


  1. Oxford Readings in Aristophanes.
  2. Similar books and articles.
  3. A Companion To Television;
  4. Programming in Visual Basic 2010 The Very Beginners Guide?
  5. [PDF Download] Oxford Readings in Aristophanes (Oxford Readings in Classical Studies) [Download]?
  6. Publications.
  7. The Works of Robert Louis Stevenson (40+ works with an active table of contents).
  8. Nor have references to Kock's edition of the comic fragments been updated to Kassel-Austin numbers, a simple but important change. The quality of some of the translations particularly from the German, but also at some points from the French , finally, is disturbingly low.

    Series by cover

    Blame for this can scarcely be placed on the individual authors, who were presumably asked to submit a preliminary translation of their essays in the reasonable expectation that revisions would be made by a native speaker. At the same time, although all Greek has been transliterated, much of it has not been translated, and the result is sentences like "The strange idea of the old men that someone who wants to stop their philodikia, which toin theoin psephismata guarantee The glossary on pp.

    German, Italian, and even Latin also persist in both footnotes and text e. Professional but non-specialist readers will find the individual essays in this volume more accessible, and will also be inclined to welcome the Introduction, which attempts to offer a synoptic overview of recent scholarship on Aristophanes. There are also a number of specific omissions and errors that will reduce the value of this essay somewhat for the average non-specialist reader. In the discussion of bibliographies p.

    Numerous typographical errors and the like are also to be found throughout this essay, 1 and it must be said in this context that the new Readings in Aristophanes as a whole is not quite up to Oxford's traditionally very high standards of editing and proofreading.

    Which Oxford World's Classic have you always wanted to read?

    Particularly unfortunate is the fact that footnotes have not been handled in a consistent fashion, but have instead been removed altogether from some essays probably appropriate for a volume of this sort , while being allowed to occupy up to half the page in others e. Nor have references to Kock's edition of the comic fragments been updated to Kassel-Austin numbers, a simple but important change.

    Oxford Readings in Aristophanes : Erich Segal :

    The quality of some of the translations particularly from the German, but also at some points from the French , finally, is disturbingly low. Blame for this can scarcely be placed on the individual authors, who were presumably asked to submit a preliminary translation of their essays in the reasonable expectation that revisions would be made by a native speaker.

    That crucial final step seems not to have been taken here, however, and while the general editor of the volume may have had too little time to attend to a seemingly minor matter of this sort, someone else clearly should have. In short, it is a pleasure to see a new volume of collected essays on Aristophanes appear. A modestly revised second edition of the Oxford Readings, perhaps a bit more carefully and consistently checked and edited, and containing a slightly different mix of material, would be welcome.


    • Oxford Scholarly Editions Online — Classics.
    • Double Eagle.
    • My Choice.
    • Greek Comedy - Bibliography.
    • Refugees: Why seeking asylum is legal and Australias policies are not.
    • Product details!
    • Review of Erich Segal (ed.), Oxford Readings in Aristophanes.

    It is nonetheless likely that the current volume will find a permanent place on the shelves of numerous undergraduate and undergraduate libraries in this country and perhaps even in the collections of some individual scholars.